I Don’t Feel Safe In My Transgender Community — Because I’m Jewish
I don’t have a place in the Chicago transgender community because I’m Jewish, and that’s a shame.
Yupa Watchanakit / Shutterstock I don’t feel welcome in the Chicago transgender community. It’s not a safe space for me, mostly because I’m Jewish.
Unfortunately, this is something that started to happen well before the now-infamous Pride weekend. I first noticed it back in February 2017, when Chicago’s trans community planned a rally for transgender rights following Trump’s executive order relating to where trans students can go to the bathroom.
The rally was being planned for a Friday night in the Chicago Loop. I’m an Orthodox trans woman who observes Shabbat, and when I spoke up about not being able to go, the thread turned anti-Semitic really quickly. Someone responded to me saying, “sounds white but okay.” The discussion then devolved into whether Ashkenazi Jews are considered white. Not helpful.
Since it was also during Shabbat, I didn’t hear about what happened during the Chicago Dyke March — where three Jewish women were kicked out for carrying rainbow flags with Jewish stars on them — until later that night. I was left feeling very disgusted and in no mood to go to or watch the Pride parade the next day. This would have been the first parade that I attended.
It wasn’t until Monday morning when I learned what happened during the parade from an organization that claims to represent the Chicago transgender community. The Trans Liberation Collective in Chicago describes itself as “a movement founded by trans organizers in Chicago, Illinois. Our goal is nothing short of full liberation for all trans people, and we will tolerate nothing about us without us!”
This group, along with members of Black Lives Matter Chicago, Jewish Voice for Peace, and other groups shut down a portion of the parade to denounce LGBTQ groups that they say overlook marginalized people.
According to their statement, they “rise in solidarity with Palestinian liberation, including the call for Boycott, Divestment, and Sanctions!” adding that, “The presence of groups like A Wider Bridge, Stand With Us, and the Israeli Consulate General dishonors the legacy of the trans women of color who galvanized our movement.”
When I saw this, I spoke out about it on their Facebook page and whoever commented in response on their behalf ignored what was in their press statement, denying that they’ve mentioned BDS in the past though reiterating they are an anti-Zionist group, and told me, “If that does not fit your needs, please find a different collective that does.”
As if things couldn’t get any worse, towards the end of July 2017, it was announced that an LGBTQ hiring fair, with an emphasis on hiring transgender and non-binary people, would be held on September 22, the second day of Rosh Hashanah.
Once again, the Jews would be left out. I’ve been unemployed since coming out in late September 2016. This would be the one chance I have to get my face and resume in front of many potential employers who want to hire transgender folks. Fortunately, I spoke up about this and was instrumental in getting it moved to a different Friday, September 29. It’s still not ideal —Yom Kippur begins that evening, which means it will be a rush to get to the early services on time, but it’s a win so I’ll take it.
But really, at a time when I don’t feel all that included in the Chicago Orthodox community because I’m transgender, I don’t really have a place in the Chicago transgender community because I’m Jewish, and that’s a shame.
Danielle Solzman is a film critic and writes about TV and Film at Solzy at the Movies. Alma is a feminist Jewish culture site from 70 Faces Media.